Wednesday, July 23, 2008

How to stop Illegal Immigration!!

I THINK THIS IS SO FUNNY!! LET ME KNOW WHAT YOU THINK!




4 comments:

chimostrufia said...

Wowwww, this is awesome. Marx will argue that the dominant ruling class has created the fear and hate for illegal immigrants. He will also argue that NAFTA and the WTO are responsible for the wave of immigrants invading our beloved settled states of america!!! Also, instead of blamming the transnational organizations that the RULING CLASS has created; they instead turn the attention to the most vulnerable, the less economically risk factor(i.e. if shift attention to NAFTA and WTO, Millioners will be loosing their piggy banks). Moreover he will urge Native Americans to start a REVOLUTION and take over their rightfully own land; the same way the settlers/immigrants took their LAND!
Durkhiem on the other hand will argue that immigrants/settlers who are against illegal immigrants are just a part of the organic society. Their hate for illegal immigrants is just a shared moral believe that has developed as a result of common commitment to common ideals and values by the members of a community. Immigration laws, he will argue, are ideals to believe in, and rules are need to guide their social life.

MT said...

yeah. "who's side are you on" in terms of explanation? both are true; both are primary.

buddy said...

i think chimostrufia did a nice job of putting this issue into the marx v. durkhiem context...

i think i'm with marx on this one, the ruling class is blaming these poor people for a problem the ruling class created...if we weren't exploiting and plundering all the resources they have in mexico, maybe they wouldn't need to come here...or rather, they wouldn't...we'd be wanting to live there

but i think the idea of the native americans having a revolution is just not possible, the poor native americans are losing their lives and thier cultures, but they aren't just being held back by the feds, it's their own tribal government keeping them down...lining their own pockets with the handouts they get from the feds, and leaving their own people to suffer...they have it twice as difficult as anyone else it seems

i've often thought, like daisy in the video, about the irony and the hypocracy of the people waging war on the new immigrants...so many times i've heard "go back to mexico" but why is no one responding with "go back to europe"?

and how to you call someone from mexico or south america anything other than "American"?

chimostrufia said...

Thank you buddy. In response to mt. I will take Marx side because Native Americans are the ones that rightfully owned America (as we know it). And yes, I know that a revolution will never be possible. There is no way to do it. We have the federal, state, and local law enforcement. The only thing I was trying to do was to talk from a Marx and Durkheim perspective (to be continue).